STAY UPDATED: Sign-up for the Kitman Labs monthly round-up of news. SUBSCRIBE NOW

CONTACT US
BLOG

The Buy vs. Build Dilemma: Making the Right Choice for An Athlete Management System

Why Building Your Own System Can Cost More Than You Think

SHARE

Share via email

Organizations managing athlete health and performance often face a critical decision: build an internal Athlete Management System (AMS) or invest in a proven, configurable platform like iP: Intelligence Platform. While the appeal of a custom-built system may seem enticing, the long-term challenges of resource allocation, scalability, security, and integration complexities often outweigh the perceived benefits.

The Reality of DIY and Building an In-House AMS

Many organizations believe building their own Athlete Management System (AMS) will provide them with a tailored solution. Common justifications include:

  • “We have our own in-house platform.”
  • “We have the in-house expertise to build our own.”
  • “Every department chooses its own individual platforms.”

However, these approaches introduce significant challenges:

  • High Costs & Resource Strain: Developing, maintaining, and scaling an in-house solution demands ongoing financial and personnel investment. Many organizations underestimate the long-term costs of software development, from hiring specialized engineers to ongoing system maintenance and support.
  • Siloed Data & Fragmentation: Multiple departments using disparate systems result in a disconnected data landscape, reduced efficiency, and limited collaboration. This increases operational complexity and limits the ability to derive insights from integrated data sets.
  • Scalability Limitations: Internal solutions often struggle to adapt to evolving organizational needs and technological advancements. What starts as a simple database can quickly become a bottleneck, requiring constant updates and reengineering efforts.  And what originates as a “custom” build quickly becomes obsolete.
  • Security & Compliance Risks: Meeting industry standards like ISO 27001 requires continuous updates and rigorous security protocols, which demand substantial expertise and oversight. Without dedicated cybersecurity teams, homegrown solutions can introduce vulnerabilities that put sensitive athlete data at risk.

Over time, these challenges compound, turning what seemed like a cost-effective, tailored solution into an ongoing struggle—one that demands more time, resources, and expertise than originally anticipated.

When Custom AMS Becomes a Burden

Many teams start down the DIY path with the best intentions—seeking control, flexibility, and a solution tailored to their exact needs. But over time, what seemed like a practical approach can become an ongoing challenge, requiring more resources, maintenance, and oversight than expected.

Does any of this sound familiar?

  • Endless Maintenance Demands – Instead of focusing on athlete health and performance, your team is spending more time managing databases, troubleshooting bugs, and maintaining system infrastructure.
  • Security & Compliance Headaches – Enterprise-grade security and compliance (ISO 27001, GDPR, HIPAA) weren’t a priority at first, but now ensuring protection and compliance is a mandate.
  • Risk of Knowledge Loss – The system is only as reliable as the people who built it. If key staff leave, does the knowledge of how to maintain and evolve your custom athlete management systems leave with them?  The price of vulnerability is high.
  • Scaling Becomes a Struggle – Expanding functionality, adding new data sources, or integrating external systems requires continuous reengineering, diverting resources from high-value priorities.
  • Siloed Data Limits Decision-Making – What was supposed to unify your information has now created bottlenecks, limiting access and collaboration across medical, performance, and coaching staff.

These challenges aren’t uncommon. Many organizations eventually find that the effort, cost, and complexity of maintaining an in-house AMS outweigh the benefits. Instead of building a system that needs constant fixing, evolving, and patching together, teams need a proven solution designed for scale, security, and seamless collaboration from day one.

 

The Smarter Approach: A Configurable Intelligence Platform

Organizations can opt for a fully integrated, configurable solution instead of struggling with the challenges of a fragmented or “custom-built” Athlete Management System (AMS). iP: Intelligence Platform goes beyond traditional AMS and EMR systems by unifying processes, data, and people in one centralized system.

Why iP: Intelligence Platform Stands Out

  • Configurability, Not Custom Chaos – Unlike legacy systems that require extensive customization, iP: Intelligence Platform allows organizations to configure proven, automated workflows and data structures to fit their needs without costly development.
  • Seamless Integration – iP acts as the central hub for all third-party vendor data – integrating all disparate data sources and providing a single source of truth for testing screening, performance, and medical data. No more struggling to stitch together disparate systems—iP does it all in one platform.
  • Proven, Scalable Solution – Designed to grow with your organization, iP eliminates costly reengineering as your needs evolve.  In addition, your platform is “future-proofed” as a result of the ongoing innovation driven by our work with the most advanced leagues, teams, and federations in elite sport – you benefit from their collective use and our continuous investment.   We ensure you stay ahead. Don’t be held back by rigid systems that can’t keep up with changing demands.
  • Enhanced Collaboration – Break down data silos and foster cross-departmental collaboration and alignment by consolidating all relevant information in a unified platform. This ensures that medical, performance, and coaching teams work from the same data set, driving informed and holistic decision-making.

 

Security & Compliance: A Critical Consideration

Security cannot be an afterthought—yet many homegrown systems lack the rigorous safeguards required to protect sensitive athlete data. iP: Intelligence Platform is built with enterprise-grade security measures, including:

  • ISO 27001 Certification – Meeting international standards for information security, ensuring that data is managed with the highest level of protection.
  • Continuous Compliance & Updates – Avoiding the pitfalls of outdated security protocols by maintaining compliance with evolving industry regulations.
  • Data Protection & Privacy – Ensuring that athlete and organizational data is stored, managed, and shared securely, mitigating risks of breaches or unauthorized access.

 

Avoid the Pitfalls of DIY

Many organizations underestimate the complexities of building their own AMS. Stitching together databases and third-party solutions often results in inefficiencies, hidden costs, and security vulnerabilities. Additionally, internal solutions often lack the flexibility and adaptability of a system built specifically for the demands of elite sports organizations. 

Before committing to a “custom” or DIY approach, evaluating the true costs and challenges is essential. Use our Buy vs. Build Checklist to assess key considerations and determine the best path forward.

 

One System, Four Powerful Solutions

Unlike fragmented solutions that rely on multiple systems for various functions, iP: Intelligence Platform combines all critical areas into a single, configurable platform.

Powered by a strong data infrastructure, iP integrates data from over 150 third-party systems, unifies workflows with customizable reporting and scheduling, and offers mobile tools for seamless engagement with both staff and athletes. With these capabilities, iP delivers four integrated solutions built for every essential aspect of athlete management, ensuring organizations stay agile, informed, and proactive.

  • Performance Medicine – A fully integrated, data-driven medical solution that centralizes all aspects of athlete health. From injury prevention to return to play, this solution provides medical staff with a comprehensive, real-time view of an athlete’s health status, treatment progress, and risk factors—all within a secure, compliant framework.
  • Performance Optimization – A solution designed to capture and analyze all performance, training, and screening data to drive proactive decision-making. With robust analytics, teams can fine-tune training programs, optimize workloads, and reduce injury risks to maximize athlete readiness and availability.
  • Coaching & Development – A data-driven solution designed to enhance player development, scouting, and progression. By centralizing data from training, games, and assessments, coaching staff can align development pathways with team philosophy, identify emerging talent, and tailor individualized training plans.
  • League Operations – A centralized system designed for leagues and federations to streamline registration and compliance, track discipline and eligibility, oversee league-wide reporting, and optimize player pathways in partnership with member clubs. By automating processes and enhancing collaboration across all stakeholders, this solution ensures seamless operations and more efficient league management. 

With iP: Intelligence Platform, organizations eliminate inefficiencies and enhance decision-making across every aspect of athlete management. Choose a system that works seamlessly across medical, performance, coaching, and operations and has been tested and proven by 2000+ of the most innovative leagues, teams and regulatory bodies in 26 countries worldwide.

Contact us to learn how iP: Intelligence Platform can elevate your organization.

RELATED POSTS

TOPICS

  • AMS
  • Athlete Management Software
  • Athlete Management System
  • Intelligence Platform
  • Performance Optimization
  • Player Performance Analysis
  • Sport Performance Analysis

stay updated

Sign up for the monthly round-up of news from Kitman Labs – new Solutions, client announcements, product enhancements, best practices, customer stories and more. Delivered to your inbox.

STAY UP-TO-DATE!

WITH KITMAN LABS NEWS

Sign up for our monthly round-up of news – new Solutions, client announcements, product enhancements, best practices, customer stories, and more.

Expert advice and industry insights delivered to your inbox

YOU ARE NOW ENTERING THE
AMERICAN
ENGLISH SITE
REDIRECTING TO